Close-up comparison of paint by numbers and diamond painting, showing a brush painting numbered canvas and a pen placing gems.

Paint by Numbers vs. Diamond Painting: An Expert Comparison

Article Summary

Both paint by numbers and diamond painting offer a relaxing, creative escape, but which one is the right choice for you? In this definitive guide, our founder William Murdock breaks down the key differences in process, final look, and creative experience to help you choose your perfect craft.

In the world of creative hobbies, two titans have emerged, captivating millions with their promise of a relaxing, rewarding, and beautiful artistic experience: paint by numbers and diamond painting. Both offer a structured path to a stunning masterpiece, but they provide very different creative journeys.

As the founder of a brand that is passionate about both of these incredible crafts, I'm often asked, "Which one is right for me?" The answer depends entirely on the kind of experience you're looking for. This expert guide will walk you through the key differences to help you find your perfect creative escape.


At a Glance: The Key Differences

An infographic comparing paint by numbers and diamond painting on key features like process, look, and experience.

The Process: Painting vs. Placing

  • Paint by Numbers: This is a classic, painterly experience. You are using brushes to apply wet acrylic paint to a canvas. It involves brush control, layering, and blending (if you choose to).
  • Diamond Painting: This is a mosaic-like craft. You use an applicator pen to pick up small, faceted resin gems (called "drills") and place them onto an adhesive, color-coded canvas. It's a clean, tactile process of building an image with sparkling dots.

The Final Look: Painterly Texture vs. Sparkling Mosaic

  • Paint by Numbers: The finished piece has the look and feel of a classic acrylic painting, with visible brushstrokes and a smooth, matte or glossy finish (depending on whether you seal it).
  • Diamond Painting: The finished piece is a glittering mosaic with incredible texture and a brilliant shine. The multi-faceted gems catch the light from every angle, creating a dynamic, sparkling effect.

The Experience: Which is Right for You?

Your personality and what you seek from a creative hobby will be the ultimate guide.

Choose Paint by Numbers If:

  • You love the traditional feel of a brush on canvas.
  • You enjoy learning classic art techniques like blending and layering.
  • You prefer a finished piece with a classic, painterly aesthetic.

Choose Diamond Painting If:

  • You love a clean, tidy, and tactile process with no mess.
  • You find a simple, repetitive, and rhythmic activity to be the most meditative.
  • You love a bold, sparkling, and highly textured final result.

The Best of Both Worlds

Ultimately, there is no "better" craft; there is only the craft that is better for you, right now. Many of our customers are passionate about both! They turn to Paint by Numbers when they crave a classic, painterly experience and to Diamond Painting when they want a clean, sparkling, and meditative session.

William Murdock, Founder & Creative Head of Paint On Numbers

About the Author

This guide was written by William Murdock. As a passionate advocate for both crafts, William believes that the most important thing is to find the creative outlet that brings you the most joy.

Ready to Find Your Perfect Creative Escape?

Whether you're drawn to the brush or the gem, your next masterpiece is waiting. Explore our collections and discover the perfect kit to start your artistic journey today.

Explore All Kits
Back to blog